INSIGHTS

Shadows of Strategy: A Shariah Analysis of Crypto Trading Strategies

Introduction to Crypto-assets

Crypto-assets are digital representations of value that leverage cryptographic encryption techniques to ensure security and decentralization. They operate on peer-to-peer networks and public ledgers known as blockchains. Crypto-assets serve various functions, including asset representation, utility access, and governance rights.

 

Types of Crypto-assets and their Shariah considerations

Crypto-assets can be categorized into several types:

  • Security Tokens – Represent ownership in financial assets and may include rights to profits, voting power, or asset claims. Shariah compliance is determined by ensuring the absence of involvement in prohibited sectors such as riba-based financial services, gambling, and non-halal industries.
  • Utility Tokens – Provide access to specific products or services and must align with Shariah principles by avoiding impermissible activities.
  • Asset-backed Tokens – Represent ownership of physical assets such as gold or oil and must ensure compliance by linking the token to tangible ownership rather than speculative valuation.
  • Governance Tokens – Grant holders decision-making rights within blockchain ecosystems, with compliance contingent upon the Shariah permissibility of the platform’s activities.
  • Platform Tokens – Serve as fuel for blockchain operations, facilitating transactions within a network, and their compliance depends on the nature of the platform’s activities.
  • Hybrid Tokens – Combine elements of different token types, requiring a comprehensive Shariah assessment based on their use case.

 

Types of Trading Orders and their Shariah aspects

Various types of trading orders exist in crypto markets, including limit orders, market orders, stop-limit orders, and trailing stop orders. These orders are generally permissible as they represent contractual agreements with brokers or agents, provided they do not involve elements of excessive uncertainty (gharar) or interest (riba).

 

Trading Strategies in Crypto Markets

Different trading strategies are commonly used in crypto markets:

  • Scalping and Day Trading – Involve short-term trades based on minor price movements. Shariah compliance is determined by the presence of ownership, risk-sharing, and avoidance of excessive speculation.
  • Swing Trading and Position Trading – Focus on longer-term market trends, aligning more closely with Shariah principles when trades are backed by actual asset ownership.
  • Range Trading and Intraday Trading – Depend on market fluctuations and must ensure adherence to Shariah guidelines regarding transparency and risk-sharing.

Non-Compliant Trading Practices
Certain trading mechanisms conflict with Shariah principles, including:

  • Margin Trading – Involves borrowing funds to amplify trading positions, which often leads to interest-based transactions.
  • Futures Contracts – Represent agreements to buy or sell an asset at a future date and are deemed non-compliant due to speculative elements and deferred settlement risks.
  • Leveraged Tokens – Provide exposure to leveraged positions without ownership of the underlying asset, making them impermissible.

 

Investment Strategies and their Shariah considerations

Crypto investment approaches such as hodling, dollar-cost averaging, and value investing focus on asset appreciation over time. While these strategies align with Shariah principles, yield-generating methods must be assessed to avoid involvement in interest-based returns.

 

Market Manipulation and Ethical Considerations

Certain market practices, including pump-and-dump schemes, whale wall spoofing, wash trading, and stop hunting, are prohibited due to their deceptive and exploitative nature. Islamic finance principles emphasize fairness, transparency, and ethical conduct in market participation.

 

Conclusion

Crypto trading and investment require careful assessment to ensure compliance with Shariah principles. Investors must consider the nature of the assets, trading strategies, and market practices while adhering to Shariah principles and rulings and regulatory guidelines

Download the full PDF report from below.

Share: